Cadbury owner wins High Court appeal over paid leave

AdNewsLocal NewsNewsLocal NewsNews HomeNewsSportCommunityTributes & FuneralsClassifiedsExplore TravelEntertainmentLifestyleRecommendedQuick LinksToday’s PaperDownload our appInteractive

PuzzlesViewJobsNetworkVideoView real estatePress Releases from AAPContact usHelp CentrePrivacy PolicyAbout usView Subscription OffersThe Examiner's complete view of propertyHome/News/Local

NewsCadbury owner wins High Court appeal over paid leaveBy Rob InglisUpdated August 13 2020 - 6:03pm, first published 6:00pmBy Rob InglisUpdated August 13 2020 - 6:03pm, first published

6:00pmFacebookTwitterWhatsappEmailCopyCadbury owner wins High Court appeal over paid leave The owners of Cadbury have had a High Court win, triumphing in a landmark case which saw them go

head-to-head with two of their employees and a trade union.

Subscribe now for unlimited access. Login or signup to continue reading

50% off EOFY SaleAll articles from our website & appThe digital version of Today's PaperCrosswords, Sudoku and TriviaAll other regional websites in your areaContinue The decision regarding

paid leave entitlements has been welcomed by the nation's peak industry association but criticised by the union movement.

Mondelez International took two Cadbury employees, Natasha Triffitt and Brendon McCormack, based at the chocolatier's Claremont factory, as well as the Australian Manufacturing Workers'

Union, to the Federal Court over a disagreement regarding paid leave.

IN OTHER NEWS:

Family before politics: Palmer and Butler find common groundJubilation for VC campaigners after decades-long battleSpike in supplies to protect Tasmanians against COVID-19Data lags mainland

on medicinal cannabis Together with the union, the employees, who work three 12-hour shifts per week, argued that they should be entitled to more personal and carer's leave than their

colleagues due to working these longer shifts.

Workers are entitled to 10 days (or 96 hours) of this leave a year under the National Employment Standards.

Mondelez told the Federal Court that if the workers took a day of personal or carer's leave, they should have the full rostered 12 hours deducted from their 96-hour total.

However, the AMWU said this put the workers at a disadvantage to those who worked standard 7.2-hour days, due to the fact their leave would dry up quicker because they worked longer shifts.

The union told the court that the workers should be entitled to 120 hours of unpaid leave, equivalent to 10 12-hour shifts.

The Federal Court ruled in their favour.

RELATED:

Business group pushes for Cadbury decision appealCadbury decision appealed to the High Court But on Thursday, the High Court overturned the original decision on appeal.

In a 4-1 decision, it was concluded the entitlement to 10 days' leave was calculated based on an employee's hours of work rather than days.

Chief Justice Susan Kiefel, Justice Geoffrey Nettle and Justice Michelle Gordon disagreed with the union's contention that all employees were entitled to 10 "working" days (time worked in a

24-hour period) of personal and carer's leave as opposed to Mondelez's contention that they were entitled to 10 "notional" days (an employee's average weekly ordinary hours divided by five).

"It would give rise to absurd results and inequitable outcomes," they said of the union's argument.

Australian Industry Group chief executive Innes Wilcox said the High Court judgment prevented "major cost implications for a very large number of businesses".

Meanwhile, Australian Council of Trade Unions secretary Sally McManus said the decision was a "very disappointing outcome".

"The federal government must amend the Fair Work Act so that every worker has access to 10 days of paid personal leave every year, no matter what hours they work," she said.

Sign up to one of our newsletters:

ShareFacebookTwitterWhatsappEmailCopyRob InglisJournalistRob Inglis is a reporter with The Examiner, covering state and federal politics. He is based in Hobart.Rob Inglis is a reporter with

The Examiner, covering state and federal politics. He is based in Hobart.More from Local NewsPolice seek information on missing tourists last seen near East CoastNo commentsWinter tells

crossbenchers my way or the highway ahead of likely election2hrs agoNo commentsWinter fires back at Tassie AFL legend after scathing no-confidence reaction2hrs agoNo commentsTeenager to

appear in court following crash that injured two pedestriansEducation Minister pays tribute to Hillcrest families left reeling by verdictLaunceston school ticks off first-time achievement,

off to state finalsNo commentsNewsletters & AlertsView all Daily

Your morning news Today's top stories curated by our news team. Also includes evening update.

Loading... Weekdays

The lunch break Grab a quick bite of today's latest news from around the region and the nation.

Loading... Weekdays

The evening wrap Catch up on the news of the day and unwind with great reading for your evening.

Loading... Weekly

Subscriber OnlyNote from the Editor Get the editor's insights: what's happening & why it matters.

Loading... Weekly

Subscriber OnlyFootyHQ Love footy? We've got all the action covered.

Loading... Weekly

Sport The latest news, results & expert analysis.

Loading... Weekly

Explore Travel Every Saturday and Tuesday, explore destinations deals, tips & travel writing to transport you around the globe.

Loading... Weekdays

The Echidna Sharp. Close to the ground. Digging deep. Your weekday morning newsletter on national affairs, politics and more.

Loading... Twice weekly

The Informer Your essential national news digest: all the big issues on Wednesday and great reading every Saturday.

Loading... Twice weekly

Voice of Real Australia Get real, Australia! Let the ACM network's editors and journalists bring you news and views from all over.

Loading... As it happens

Subscriber OnlySpecial Reports Get the very best journalism from The Examiner by signing up to our special reports.

Loading... Weekly

Motoring Get news, reviews and expert insights every Thursday from CarExpert, ACM's exclusive motoring partner.

Loading... As it happens

Breaking news alert Be the first to know when news breaks.

Loading... Daily

Subscriber OnlyToday's Paper Alert Your digital replica of Today's Paper. Ready to read from 5am!

Loading... Daily

Subscriber OnlyYour favourite puzzles Test your skills with interactive crosswords, sudoku & trivia. Fresh daily!

Loading... Advertisement

Ad Advertisement

AdAustralian Community MediaACM WebsiteConditions of UsePrivacyTerms and Conditions - Digital SubscriptionTerms and Conditions - Newspaper SubscriptionThe ExaminerContactAbout UsWorking With

UsToday's PaperCommenting GuidelinesView Property EditionHelp CentreOur SitesViewExploreView InsuranceBeevoPlace an AdClassifiedsCarsTributes & FuneralsCelebrationsPromo

CodesAgTraderMeHelpFarmer's FinanceGarage SalesSubmitSend a letter to the EditorSend Us Your News