Eighteenth and nineteenth century dental restoration, treatment and consequences in a british nobleman

KEY POINTS * An unusual example of late eighteenth/early nineteenth century dentistry in a nobleman excavated from beneath a church in Kent. * The first ever reported case of enamel erosion

of the labial surface of anterior dentition in the UK. * Discussion and description of the possible effects on dental enamel of the use of dental tinctures. * Scientific analysis of dental

restorations from this period ABSTRACT This paper examines unusual eighteenth and nineteenth century dental treatment and its consequences, in a nobleman excavated from beneath St.

Nicholas' Church, Sevenoaks, Kent, UK in the early 1990s. This rare archaeological case exhibits erosion of dental enamel on the labial surface of all the anterior dentition. A

programme of historical research suggests that this might be attributed to the application of an acid-based dental tincture or the use of an abrasive substance to whiten the teeth.

Palliative treatment for the consequence of this application was prescribed by Dr Robert Blake of Dublin. Further, it bears witness to three dental restorations, two of gold and one tin. The

two gold (foil) fillings are an occlusal in the upper-right second molar and a cervical on the labial surface of the upper left canine. The tin filling is an occlusal in the upper left

second molar. Excavation of the carious tissue appears to have been undertaken using a spoon shaped implement. You have full access to this article via your institution. Download PDF SIMILAR

CONTENT BEING VIEWED BY OTHERS NUALA MARY BRIGID MITZI MACEY-DARE (NÉE COYLE) (1934-2022): LEADING COMMUNITY DENTIST, FORENSIC ODONTOLOGIST AND HER FAMILY Article 28 June 2024 INSIGNIA OF

THE ROYAL ARMY DENTAL CORPS AND COMMONWEALTH DENTAL CORPS Article Open access 11 March 2022 NON-MASTICATORY STRIATIONS ON HUMAN TEETH FROM THE BRITISH UPPER PALAEOLITHIC TO THE NEOLITHIC

Article Open access 05 January 2024 MAIN Archaeological excavation beneath St. Nicholas Church, Sevenoaks, Kent, England recovered around 450 burials, 84 of which were post medieval and

recovered from lead coffins with legible breast-plates stating their name, age and date of death.1 The remains were subject to a reburial order and consequently, only briefly available for

examination. This paper concerns the oral health, dental restorations and treatment evident in the remains of Charles Whitworth, who had been buried in an elaborately decorated

triple-shelled lead coffin2 with a well-preserved brass breast-plate. This was inscribed: 'The Right Honourable Charles Earl Whitworth, Viscount Whitworth of Adgbaston, Baron Adgbaston

in the County of Stafford, Lord Whitworth of Newport Pratt in the County of Galway in the peerage of Ireland, Knight Grand Cross of the Bath and a Privy Counsellor, Died 13 May 1825'

(sic). He died aged 71 years. Whitworth's dentition provided a brief opportunity to examine restoration techniques that must have been in use before his death in 1825. It was notable

because he had three dental restorations in his upper dentition. Gold fillings in the upper-left canine and right second molar, and a black material in the upper-left second molar.

Post-medieval dental restorations are rare in the archaeological literature3,4 reflecting the expensive nature of such treatment, its consequent exclusivity, and the small number of

controlled exhumations and archaeological excavations of this period. Further to this, Whitworth's anterior upper and lower dentition exhibited an extremely rare loss of labial dental

enamel. This was associated with the cemento-enamel junction, resembling arrested caries (Fig. 1) and is the first instance of this condition to be reported in British archaeological

material. Enamel erosion is the dissolution of the surface enamel (apatite) by a physicochemical process involving acids.5 While there is a published literature on erosion of the lingual

surface of dentition, there has been less recent interest in labial erosion. The literature on enamel erosion and abrasion considers its relationship to such factors as dietary,

regurgitative and industrial erosion,6 consumption of acidic foods and drinks and modern dental hygiene.7,8,9 In an eighteenth and nineteenth century context, the loss of labial enamel on

anterior teeth, particularly along the cemento-enamel junction, is likely to reflect the use of an abrasive tooth powder or an acidic and erosive dental tincture. Such treatments were

advocated to: '...eradicate the scurvy and tartar from the gums; make the teeth, however yellow, beautifully white; fasten such as are loose...' (Advertising for Hudson's

botanic tooth-powder and tincture).10 CHARLES WHITWORTH (1752–1825) Whitworth had a varied military and diplomatic career. Of relevance here, he was Lord Lieutenant of Ireland from

1813–1817. Thereafter spending most of his time at Knole, near Sevenoaks, Kent, dying there on 13 May 1825.11,12,13 Whitworth and his wife, the widowed Duchess of Dorset, were extremely

wealthy aristocrats, and prodigious spenders. They were supplied by the highest quality establishments in London, Paris, Dublin and elsewhere. Their scrupulous keeping of accounts and

records12 of both a personal and financial nature, particularly in relation to apothecaries, druggists and dentists proved to be relevant to this research.14 WHITWORTH'S DENTAL HEALTH A

range of macroscopic and microscopic analysis was undertaken examining Whitworth's dental and oral health and restorations. He had clearly experienced considerable dental disease

during his lifetime. This is reflected not only in the presence of dental restorations, but also in the antemortem loss of all lower left molars and the first right molar, the crypt of which

was still remodelling (Fig. 2). The upper left first molar and right second premolar, and right first and third molars were also lost ante-mortem, though a fragment of the root remained

from the right first molar. Extant caries were evident on the upper left first premolar with the entire crown of the adjacent canine having been destroyed. Apical abscesses (buccal) were

associated with the upper right second molar (tooth with the tin filling) and the lower right first molar. Whitworth had an edge to edge bite and consequently, marked attrition to the

incisal edge of his central and lateral incisors. His upper left third molar had not erupted. THE RESTORATIONS – REMOVAL OF CARIOUS TISSUE The gold restoration in the upper-right second

molar was deliberately and easily dislodged during examination to provide an opportunity to examine the excavated surface of the cavity, using scanning electron microscopy (SEM), in order to

assess the method of excavation, and to examine the filling itself in more detail (Fig. 3). There were roughly parallel U-shaped marks running around the tooth cavity (Fig. 4), denoting

excavation using a blunt edged instrument, with irregular vertical cracks running down into the cavity. It is impossible to assess if the former were caused by the use of such drills as were

available at that time. The latter may reflect drying out cracks in the dentine. THE RESTORATIONS – FILLING MATERIALS The filling materials used in the occlusal surface of this tooth and

the anterior enamel/cementum junction of the upper left canine, were examined using an energy dispersive x-ray detector (EDX) fitted to the SEM. This proved to be high carat gold foil that

appears to have been condensed and pushed into the cavity. In the case of the molar, the gold foil appears to have been applied in a single application (Fig. 3). Crushing and deformation of

the material on the occlusal surface had occurred, as would be expected with such a soft material. Two applications of foil appear to have been used for the canine (examined after being

sectioned and polished – the teeth were extracted from the maxilla and set in a polymer cast before sectioning longitudinally with a diamond saw; micrographs were taken using an Hitachi

S-450 scanning electron microscope) (Figs 5a and b). The first was much less firmly compressed than the latter. This filling does not appear to be well adapted although there is no evidence

that carious decay continued after the restoration. Gold had been in use as a filling material since at least 1516, though only rarely, and was evident in two individuals at Christ Church,

Spitalfields both of whom were interred prior to 1809.3 The third filling, in the occlusal surface of the upper left second molar, was analysed initially by EDX. This showed the filling to

be largely of tin with a trace of antimony, a commonly found impurity in tin (A small amount of filling was removed using a tungsten carbide tipped dental rasp. This was weighed and treated

overnight with a 1:2 mixture of hydrochloric (36%) and nitric (70%) acids. The solution was then made up to a standard volume with distilled water and the solution reserved for analysis by

AAS. The analysis was performed using a ATI-Unicam atomic absorption spectrophotometer using an air/acetylene fuel mixture with a 100 mm burner). Little is published about the use of tin as

a filling material. Further analysis was undertaken using atomic absorption spectrometry (AAS) with standard techniques for cadmium, lead and antimony. These showed that the filling material

was tin with no deliberately added elements (see Table 1). Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy did not detect any organic residue from a glue or other adhesive matrix. Unfortunately,

historical research has shed no light on the timing and provenance of Whitworth's dental restorations. The only records that survive for his dental care relate to bills from a Dublin

tradesman, Alfred de Lessart15 and date to 1823–24. Since Whitworth was in Dublin between 1813 and 1817, it may be reasonable to suppose that he first sought relief and/or treatment there

during this period and continued to follow advice and treatment given at that time. DESTRUCTION OF THE LABIAL ENAMEL OF THE ANTERIOR DENTITION The destruction of buccolabial enamel on the

surviving anterior dentition is shown in Figure 1. This was particularly focussed on the cementum/enamel junction in most cases and was most severe on the upper left incisors where the

anterior enamel was totally destroyed. While this initially appeared to be arrested caries, the contiguous nature (Fig. 2) and extent of the loss cast doubt on this diagnosis as did the hard

nature of the surface of the teeth.9 Furthermore, when clean, the affected areas displayed the typical clear edged, disc-shaped, yellowish cavities described in Stone which are commonly

associated with erosion.9 Subsequent examination, when combined with a programme of targetted historical research, suggested that the enamel may have been eroded by a destructive agent. That

the pathology is greater on the left side, particularly of the upper dentition, could suggest that a right-handed man was applying an abrasive or erosive substances on a tooth brush, or

similar, and rubbing his teeth.9 The nature of that agent, was investigated by recourse to contemporary commentary and treatises. Historical research revealed that Whitworth was consulting a

dentist, Alfred De Lessart, of No. 7 William Street, Dublin during his latter years.15 His purchases from Lessart included 'Dr Blake's tooth-powder' and 'Dr Blake's

tincture'. TOOTH POWDERS AND DENTAL TINCTURES Patented tinctures and powders proliferated in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries particularly in response to periodontal disease and

the removal of calculus. Most early potions comprise abrasive pastes including such substances as shell, coral and ground pebbles.10 Others could be harmless16,17 while some could be highly

acidic often based on tartaric acid.16 However, while cleaning teeth and gums with tinctures with an acid or abrasive base would have removed calculus, it would also have etched and abraded

the dental enamel.16 Despite the consequences of using dental tinctures being known and clinically demonstrated as early as 1768,16 Figures 1 and 2 suggest that Whitworth might well have

resorted to the use of such a substance to redress an oral health problem. A contemporary pharmacopoeia lists 12 tooth powders, most of which contained cream of tartar and only two of which

were relatively harmless.18 The siting of Whitworth's lower enamel loss in particular, would suggest that he was aiming to remove or resolve a condition along the enamel/cementum

junction, possibly calculus (though there is no evidence of calculus on his posterior teeth), or halt receding gums. Calculus is not uncommonly seen in this position in archaeological

material. Alternatively, brushing teeth in a horizontal direction may produce wear at the cervical margin.9 With his upper dentition it is likely that he was also concerned to whiten his

teeth as the erosion is more widespread. If this was so, was Dr Blake's tincture or powder responsible? DR BLAKE AND HIS TINCTURE Dr Blake was almost certainly Robert Blake MD, who by

1803 was Dublin's leading dentist, practising from 19 William Street (a few doors away from Lessart's premises). He had developed a large practice by 1821 when he was appointed as

the first Irish state dentist.19,20 He died in 1822. It would appear, therefore, that Blake was one of Dublin's foremost dentists during Whitworth's sojourn there as lord

lieutenant in 1813–17. As such it would have been entirely appropriate for Blake to have ministered to Whitworth. Perhaps the appearance of Dr Blake's tincture in Whitworth's

records in the years 1823–24 is explained by Blake's death the previous year, and a new supplier (Lessart) taking over his business. The formulas for Dr Blake's tincture and powder

are not, unfortunately, included in any contemporary pharmacopoeia.18 In his published work,21 Blake was very critical of tooth powders, essences and lotions in widespread usage, because he

recognised and had proved by experiment their corrosive effect. Consequently, it seems unlikely that his products were responsible for the destruction of Whitworth's dental enamel.

Dental practitioners of his own and subsequent generations praised Blake's work,20 and his enlightened views have been recognised by modern historians of dentistry.22 It is possible,

that the tincture and powder which bore his name may well have been taken by Whitworth as palliatives to mollify the painful effects of earlier damage caused possibly by tartaric acid in

tooth-cleaning preparations or abrasive powders or pastes. CONCLUSION This study examining dental restorations confirms some of the techniques and developments described in the historical

literature and provides useful additional detail relating to their practice and effectiveness. Examination of the loss of enamel on the labial surface of Whitworth's anterior dentition

suggests that efforts to whiten his teeth, and possibly remove calculus, proved to be extremely damaging to his oral health. Given that most post-medieval excavations of cemetery assemblages

are those of the middle or upper socio-economic classes, it seems improbable that this is the only example in British museum collections. Recording conditions such as erosion or abrasion

are not standard procedures in UK anthropology, consequently, other cases may exist unrecorded. It is considered that awareness of this condition would be increased by its inclusion in

standard anthropological recording systems. REFERENCES * Boyle A, Keevill G . To the praise of the dead and anatomie: The analysis of post-medieval burials at St Nicholas, Sevenoaks, Kent.

_In_ M. Cox M. (ed). _Grave concerns: death and burial in post-medieval England 1700-1850._ pp85-99. York: Council for British Archaeology, 1998. Google Scholar  * Reeve J, Adams M . _The

Spitalfields Project Volume 1 – The Archaeology: Across the Styx_. York: Council for British Archaeology, 1993. Google Scholar  * Whittaker D . Oral Health.. _In_ Molleson T, Cox M (eds).

_The Spitalfields Project Vol 2 – the Anthropology: The Middling Sort_. pp 49–63. York: Council for British Archaeology. 1993. Google Scholar  * Glenner R A, Willey P, Sledzik P S, Junger E

P . Dental fillings from Civil War skulls: what do they tell us? _J Am Dent Ass_ 1996; 127: 1671–1677. Article  Google Scholar  * Ferguson D B . _Oral Bioscience_. Edinburgh: Churchill

Livingstone, 1999. Google Scholar  * Smith B G N, Knight J K A . Comparison of patterns of tooth wear with aetiological factors. _Br Dent J_ 1984; 157: 16–19. Article  Google Scholar  * Robb

N, Cruwys E, Smith B G N . Regurgitative erosion as a possible cause of tooth wear in ancient British populations. _Archs Oral Biol_ 1991; 36: 595–602. Article  Google Scholar  * Irish J P

. First evidence of LSAMAT in non native Americans – historic Senegalese from West Africa. _Am J Phys Anthrop_ 1997; 102: 141–146. Article  Google Scholar  * Farmer E D, Lawton F E .

_Stone's Oral and Dental Diseases_. Edinburgh and London: E & S Livingstone Ltd, 1966. Google Scholar  * Bennion E . _Antique Dental Instruments_. London: Sotheby's, 1986.

Google Scholar  * Anon . _Lord Charles Whitworth, Public characters of 1805_. London: Publisher not stated, 1805. Google Scholar  * Sackville-West V . _Knole and the Sackvilles_. London:

Heineman, 1922. Google Scholar  * Kent Archives Office . _Maidstone_. CPU U269 A252. * _Their records survive in the Sackville Manuscripts (CKS U269) in the Centre for Kentish Studies (Kent

Archives Office, Maidstone). Some official and private papers also exist in the Public Records Office, Kew. For the purposes of this paper, the most important accumulation at CKS is a series

of vouchers, bills and receipts (CKS U269 A252) which date from 1798 to 1825. Several thousands of such items have been examined._. * _CPU U269 A252/35 Bill to Whitworth from Lessart,

Dublin 1824; A252/36 Bill from Lessart 1824._. * Hillam C . _Brass plate and brazen impudence: dental practice in the provinces, 1755-1855_. Liverpool: Liverpool University Press, 1990.

Google Scholar  * Brown P S . Medicines advertised in 18th century Bath newspapers. _Med Hist_ 1976; 20: 152–168. Article  Google Scholar  * Gray S F . _A supplement to the pharmacopoeia;

being a treatise on pharmacology in general_. 3RD ED. London. Publisher not stated. 1824. Google Scholar  * Cohen R A . A general history of dentistry from the 18th century, with special

reference to Irish practitioners. _Irish J Med Sci 6th Series_. 1952; 315: 128–135. Google Scholar  * Cameron, Sir Charles . _History of the Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland and of the

Irish School of Medicine_. Dublin: Fannin and Co., 1886. Google Scholar  * Blake R . _An essay on the structure and formation of the teeth in man and various animals_. Dublin: William

Porter, 1981. Google Scholar  * Held A J . _Periodontology, from its origins up to 1980: a survey_. Boston: Birkhauser, 1989. Google Scholar  Download references ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Thanks are

due to the Parochial Church Council, St Nicholas' Church, Sevenoaks and the Oxford Archaeological Unit for providing the brief opportunity to examine this unusual and important 19th

century skull. The School of Conservation Sciences, Bournemouth University provided financial support. Angela Boyle provided background information to the excavations at St Nicholas'

Church, Sevenoaks, Dr John Chandler undertook historical research into Whitworth's life and dental history and Paul Kneller and Rob Haslam undertook the scientific analysis of the

dental restorations. Staff at the Centre for Kentish Studies, Maidstone and the Wellcome Institute Library, London are thanked for their assistance as are the anonymous referees and Tony

Rhodes and Julian Mitchell for their helpful comments. AUTHOR INFORMATION AUTHORS AND AFFILIATIONS * Professor of Forensic Archaeology and Anthropology, School of Conservation Sciences,

Bournemouth University, Talbot Campus, Poole, BH12 5BB, Dorset M Cox * Historian, Salisbury and South Wiltshire Museum, The King's House, 65 The Close, Salisbury, SP1 2EN, Wiltshire J

Chandler * Osteoarchaeologist, Oxford Archaeological Unit, Janus House, Osney Mead, Oxford, OX2 0ES A Boyle * Senior Lecturer in Environmental Sciences, School of Conservation Sciences,

Bournemouth University, Talbot Campus, Poole, BH12 5BB, Dorset P Kneller * Director of Investigative Support Unit, School of Conservation Sciences, Bournemouth University, Talbot Campus,

Poole, BH12 5BB, Dorset R Haslam Authors * M Cox View author publications You can also search for this author inPubMed Google Scholar * J Chandler View author publications You can also

search for this author inPubMed Google Scholar * A Boyle View author publications You can also search for this author inPubMed Google Scholar * P Kneller View author publications You can

also search for this author inPubMed Google Scholar * R Haslam View author publications You can also search for this author inPubMed Google Scholar CORRESPONDING AUTHOR Correspondence to M

Cox. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION REFEREED PAPER RIGHTS AND PERMISSIONS Reprints and permissions ABOUT THIS ARTICLE CITE THIS ARTICLE Cox, M., Chandler, J., Boyle, A. _et al._ Eighteenth and

nineteenth century dental restoration, treatment and consequences in a British nobleman. _Br Dent J_ 189, 593–596 (2000). https://doi.org/10.1038/sj.bdj.4800839 Download citation * Received:

20 May 1999 * Accepted: 12 April 2000 * Published: 09 December 2000 * Issue Date: 09 December 2000 * DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/sj.bdj.4800839 SHARE THIS ARTICLE Anyone you share the

following link with will be able to read this content: Get shareable link Sorry, a shareable link is not currently available for this article. Copy to clipboard Provided by the Springer

Nature SharedIt content-sharing initiative