Trump? Carson? Here's who should drop out

With just over two weeks to go until actual voting begins, there are very few opportunities for candidates to shift the trajectory of the race. Thursday night's debate was one of them. While

I don't think much will change after last night's performance, we did learn a few things... Here are my takeaways.

Donald Trump is really good — good at politics. Now to be clear, I definitely don't think he's qualified to serve as president. And, I'm not saying he'd be a great nominee for the GOP. In

fact, his nomination would be a disaster for the Republican Party. But, he's very smart, very skilled, and he's much better at politics than most people give him credit for. When it comes to

message discipline, he's easily one of the best ever. This is why there's a small but growing chorus of smart people who think he could beat Hillary Clinton in a general election.

While Senator Ted Cruz took incoming from several candidates, the Rubio hits seemed especially tough and appeared to really annoy Cruz. These two obviously know each other from the Senate

and it seems as if neither can understand why the other is standing on stage. Watch for this conflict to heat up even more than is obvious today.

Nothing occurred at last night's debate that will cause the race to fundamentally alter course. And, in this contest, beyond money (which has mattered little in this race), debates are the

only yardstick we've had to measure the candidates' success. This has been bad for establishment candidates. They killed the straw polls, a metric that could have helped a few of them. Cruz

has benefited most from the intense focus on these debates.

Thursday night's debate was easily the most substantive debate of the cycle and the primary reason was that there were fewer candidates on the stage. The Republican National Committee and

future debate hosts should ensure there are no more than six candidates on the main stage. And, for that matter, they should end the undercard debates. They made sense early on. But, at this

point in the cycle, they are a waste of everyone's time.

Ben Carson continues to lack the substance necessary to wage an effective general election campaign and to serve as president. Last night, was important for him and he blew an opportunity to

prove he belongs on that stage. And, finally, his campaign appears to be in total disarray, with more staff departing by the day. One can only conclude that his presence is hurting the

Republican Party's chance to nominate the best candidate. His 9 or 10 percent of the vote would do a lot to boost Jeb Bush, Marco Rubio or one of the other mainstream governors.

Commentary by Sara Taylor Fagen, a partner at DDC Advocacy and a former Political Director for President George W. Bush. She is also a CNBC contributor. Follow her on Twitter @sarafagen2.

Sign up for free newsletters and get more CNBC delivered to your inbox

Get this delivered to your inbox, and more info about our products and services.

© 2025 CNBC LLC. All Rights Reserved. A Division of NBCUniversal